Thursday, June 19, 2008

Dear BBC!

Every now and then I see something in the news that makes my blood boil. Not because of the story itself, but because of the way it is reported.

Here’s an example from the BBC: "Q&A: What's behind power price rise?".

When explaining that energy prices will rise by 25-40% over the coming year, the BBC says “British Gas, EDF and Npower have all highlighted the fact that wholesale prices have surged since February last year.” They go on to mention that one reason for the rising wholesale price of gas is that that North Sea gas production "has been declining faster than was expected."

However, anyone with a memory of the deregluation in the early 90s, knows that British Gas and its parent company, started burning off gas reserves to generate electricity. It was seen as a cheap alternative to coal and at the time, nuclear power was untouchable (the Sizewell B reprocessing plant had opened to much ire, around that time). Gas-fired turbine stations were a quick and relatively cheap alternative to either traditional option. The Conservative administration being too dim to see the potential of industries like solar, wind, tidal power, etc, the British government signed off legislation to make it happen (this was the administration that bought into the European Exchange Rate mechanism at a 15% premium over the previous 10 year average value of the Pound and then blew the UK treasury and the economy – with 15% interest rates - trying to stay in it).

So, since the mid 1990s British Gas has been merrily burning Britain’s gas reserves to supply to sell cheaper electricity, whilst just as merrily failing to look for or find more reserves, or do very much (until 2005) about sourcing replacement supplies from elsewhere.

In fact, one would suggest that the only way one could NOT foresee the rapid deletion of Britain's gas reserves through electricity generation AND the subsequent hike in gas prices (in a sellers’ market price), AND its effect on wholesale gas prices (decreasing supply, increasing demand), is to have been fixated on the fast Buck being made by getting into electricity generation. One would go so far as to point out that the legendary, nay, the original ‘Fat Cats’ of BG have lined their pockets, and enriched shareholders, whilst systematically undermining both their business and the entire UK. They have gone from a profitable exporter, to market-begging importer, and taken the UK with them.

Saturday, June 7, 2008

Oil prices and the rest of us

Earlier this century (good Lord, I sound old!), when everyone was clamouring about the invasion of Iraq being about grabbing Iraqi oil. The theory was Big Oil had paid for George Bush to get elected so that he would invade Iraq, privatise Iraq's oil and hand it over to Exxon Mobil, etc. The second strand of the argument was that by invading Iraq, the US would pull Iraq out of OPEC, ramp up production and crush oil prices with over production.

As we all know, the result was actually somewhat different. Iraq is still in OPEC, production is barely different to when Iraq was embargoed under United Nations sanctions and oil is now $138 a barrel, as I write this.

People have speculated that the original plan, above, was dropped when the realities of the situation in Iraq, post Saddam, became evident. Certainly the underwhelming lack of comprehension was staggering and contrasts poorly with the post invasion preparations & results in Kossovo and Bosnia.

Back in 2001-03, I was travelling to America frequently and was curious about all the arguments in the press and the things people were saying about oil. The thing I noticed was that the oil industry was staying conspicuously quiet on the subject and when they did make a statement it was to the effect that there should be more supply. That struck me as a little odd, given that the oil industry was one of the largest contributors to the 2000 Bush election campaign.

Being a naturally cynical person, I wondered why they would back a President who was clearly bent on invading Iraq, also tightly bound to neo-conservatives who dreamed of smashing OPEC, etc.? That would depress the price of oil and make them all poorer. That just didn't make sense.

Then it occurred to me: Big Oil was playing a double game. They didn't want Iraq's oil (and given who badly Iraq has worked out since, who would?), they wanted access to oil in a nice stable country with a compliant government. Somewhere closer to home. In fact, somewhere like the USA!

In 2003 the Bush administration began trying to push for greater drilling rights in American territories. The opening up of the ANWR (Arctic National Wildlife Refuge) was put forward. And shot down in Congress. They tried again in 2004 (with oil around $50 a barrel) and failed.

After re-election, Bush finally managed to get through legislation to open ANWR, only threatened by the possible listing of Polar Bears as an endangered species (since they live throughout the area), but that was delayed and delayed.

Now, if you read the media on ANWR and the current oil price spike you will find only stories about how what would solve the problem is more supply; that Supply is flat, whilst demand is growing, etc. Here's what the U.S. energy secretary had to say:

There, in a nutshell, ladies and gentlemen is one major reason for Oil being $138 a barrel. People with enough money to drive it up to $150-$200 a barrel want to pressure your governments to allow them to drill anywhere they please(like they used to, in the good old days).
They are also driving up the price to the point that countries that subsidise oil prices are forced to quit the practice. That will have the effect of crimping demand in those countries, and on a positive note, might move them to greater energy efficiency (as it is in the US), but the price will be a global recession and countless revolutions, just as we saw in Indonesia when Suharto fell.
Meanwhile, the likes of you and me, will continue to have little choice but to suck it up and pay through the nose, because the folks in charge have so little idea of what the consequences of their actions are on little people.