The scheme has some caveats, such as that the vehicle being traded in must get less than 18mpg and be more than seven years old, and the new vehicle has to get at least 25mpg. The old vehicle is simply crushed, rather than being resold.
According to a report on Bloomberg.com:
"Vehicles traded in under the program averaged 15.8 miles per gallon, compared with 25.4 miles per gallon for the new purchases, or a 61 percent improvement, according to the Transportation Department data."
That's great news for the pockets of everyone buying a new car, and hopefully puts some more money back into other parts of the economy, as well as retaining some of America's money in the US (well, at least until Walmart pays its suppliers in China, I guess!)
Meanwhile, a few people have complained that all the cars being crushed will raise the price of used cars to the point that the poor - who can't afford new cars - won't be able to afford used vehicles either and will be stuck without transportation (remembering that America is a land with comparatively few public transport alternatives). This sounds terribly important, but it ignores the fundamental law of supply & demand: despite a shortage of supply, if there are no buyers for used vehicles, the price will fall until either there are buyers or the scrap value of the vehicle is more than the resale price.
However, even if this does drive up the price of used cars, there are several further benefit to the economy, consumers and manufacturers:
- Higher resale values will put more money in the pockets of consumers trading in for a new car
- This will make new cars effectively cheaper since the price gap between a trade-in and new car will decrease, saving consumers money, which they will spend elsewhere (bringing in tax revenues)
- Financing a small purchase cost will leave more money in the pockets of consumers who will spend it elsewhere (bringing in tax revenues)
- Manufacturers may be able to finally raise prices since the depreciation of products (coupled with 30 years of stagnated earnings for the average American) has hampered the ability of manufacturers to increase prices (which would bring in more tax revenues)
- Increased new car prices would help GM & Chrysler repay government loans (and Ford could start paying their mortgages off)
- Increased demand means clearing inventories and, over a long enough period, stimulates production of new vehicles which adds earnings, which pay taxes, which means the money laid out comes back.