UPDATED:
US Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner is proposing that mortgage companies Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac should be broken up. For my UK readers, these to institutions are government backed private entities (oxymoronic!) that buy up mortgages under $420,000 written by other instituions, who collect fees when they write those mortgages, when they sell them to Fannie & Freddie, and when they service the mortgages by collecting payments from borrowers.
The only problem with Fannie & Freddie is that they bought a lot of mortgages written by the same lousy banks that now stand to profit from their abolition. Those banks will then replace the long-term fixed mortgages with Adjustable Rate Mortgages, or ARMs, and sold on to 'investment banks', much as they and their subsidiaries did throughout the property bubble of the last 10 years .
See, the problem isn't that someone packages mortgages into securities and those securities are sold off to investors. The problem comes from the fact that all the incentives for all the players were at the point when they sold the things: originate a mortgage? Kerching! Sell it on to a bank? Kerching!! Bank sells it on to investment banks and collects servicing fees? Kerching!! Kerching!!! Investment bank packages the mortgage into a 'security' and flogs it to an investor? KERCHING!!!!!!
The trouble with this process for the last 10 years is that the unregulated mortgage industry was writing mortgages for anyone with a pulse (and sometimes without!) and selling them mortgages that would, eventually adjust. No problem, with that, so long as the borrow understands that rates are at historic lows and can only go up. But the sellers didn't include that in their literature's large print. So as more and more borrowers were 'qaulified' for these nonsense loans, the property market boomed and prices soared.
Again, that isn't a problem so long as the risk of people not being able to afford those mortgages when the rate adjusts and defalts start occuring was built in to the pricing of those mortgage rates. But it wasn't. The experts on at the Wall Street investment banks, like Bear Stearns (BS), Lehman Brothers and Merril Lynch were too busy counting the bonuses from all the Mortgage Backed Securities they are flogging off to pension funds, etc, to figure out that when all those short-term fixed rates adjusted after the Federal Reserve rates had risen, there would be a massive defalt.
Driving the mortgage bus whilst under the influence of bonuses, again
The problem with the investment banks was that they were relying on computer models to predict the future and those models were built on historic data, which is to say, data from the period when mortgages were dominated by FIXED rate mortgages backed by Fannie & Freddie. Those fixed rates gave the US real estate market a degree of stability missing in almost any other market, and allow prices to remain fairly resilient, with very little corrective price movement because properly qualified (i.e., affordable) mortgages which never increase, allow people to build equity faster.
However, what the computer models didn't take into account was the effect of inflating the property valuations with Ninja loans, and teaser rates that increased short-term buying power. They also didn't take into account what would happen when all those mortgages came to reset and interest rates had reset. If you recall, the Fed rate rose from 0.5% to over 5%, and that increase was passed on to ARM borrowers when they short fixed rates evaporated.
So why couldn't they see this coming but anyone could have? Very simply, they either didn't want to know, or they hadn't bothered to look a market dominated by ARMs, like the UK.
Anyone with a single OUNCE of nonce would take a look at the UK mortgage industry and the state of real estate there and see that shunting everyone into
ARMs is just a disaster! Not once, but TWICE over in a 20 year period.
Those who forget history's lessons are bound to repeat them
In the late 80s, the Conservative government in the UK played 'bait & switch' with taxes to lower income tax rates whilst abolishing tax breaks for individuals (as well as effectively lowering
thresholds at which tax rates applied to earnings, but that's another issue). This included the mortgage interest tax relief and married man's tax allowance, which promptly drove up house prices by well over 100% in a 5 year period.
Unfortunately, since all those mortgage rates were adjustable, when government policies, such as over-valuing the Pound by 20% in the European Exchange Rate Mechanism ('strong Dollar' policy, anyone?), crushed the economy, widening the trade and government deficits. Those policies also caused the Bank of England interest rates to rise as high as 15% and all the mortgage rates followed, pretty much immediately. Foreclosures rocketed and prices collapsed back down by 30-40%.
Now some may consider that the remaining 60% gain in house prices was a pretty good return (for those who managed to keep their homes), but let me point out that the
UK's inflation rate through from 1985-96 was running at an average of 5-8%, so instead of the bust leaving a 60% gain, what you actually had was a residual gain of roughly 6% per year on average, which was barely keeping pace with inflation (just like wages).
If you think the UK mortgage industry learnt ANYTHING from the debacle of the early 90s, you are sorely mistaken. Within five years of the 1992 slump, the UK mortgage industry was selling all the dodgy mortgage products seen in the recent US bubble market ('Ninja' loans, etc), which proliferated in the late 90s and early 2000s thanks to a regulation-adverse Labour government, who failed to learn any of the lessons that they had called for from the opposition benches.
Want to see what the result is? Foreclosures, bankruptcies, homelessness, and collapsing house prices - oh, and collapsing banks, too! 2010 was 1992
redux, but this time the banks managed to collapse themselves as well as the housing market!
Those who forget history's lessons are bound to repeat them (geddit?)
As a plan for demonstrating that the private sector is just as capable of wrecking mortgage and banking industry, it's genius. But it's comparable to Republican's 'starve the beast' theory of wrecking government to prove that 'government doesn't work'.
If that sounds like a recipe for fixing what ailed the US real estate market these last 10 years, then you, dear reader, are a fool and should expect to be parted from your money soon.
UPDATE I: As I recently explained to someone, I am often right about things I would rather be wrong about. A case in point: "
Federal Retreat on Bigger Loans Rattles Housing"
I told you the Invisible Hand still needs the protection of the Government Glove