Tuesday, February 26, 2008

Congestion, charging, and scheming

The mayor of New York has announced that he wants to impose a Congestions charge on vehicles driving into Manhatten, below 60th Street (for those unfamiliar with NYC, the streets run East-West and Avenues run North-South, so 60th St. is somewhere north of Central Park). An advertising campaign is being launched on NYC public transport to encourage riders to back the scheme.

This "seems" like a good idea, so long as they avoid a lot of the nonsense that goes along with the London example.

I used to live in London, both outside and inside the Congestion Charge Zone. As an outsider, it was an inconvenience, but at least the money went to providing more public transport and as I didn't have to drive into central London during its hours of operation (7am-6:30pm) it wasn't problem very often.

As an insider, I found it great to have less polution, and the notoriously expensive cab rides were a lot quicker (thanks to less traffic) was great. However, the rules for residents within the zone were ridiculously restrictive.

I walked to work and there was ample public transport so I didn't need to use my car at all during the hours the the CCZ was in operation. It was a luxury, but useful when we had lots of shopping or wanted to go beyond Greater London, where privatized railways are both inefficient and expensive. However, about once every couple of months I had to take the car out of the zone. Invariably I was leaving the zone to go somewhere else, but even though was leaving and removing my car from the zone, I was still liable to pay the full charge driving 3 blocks to the CCZ boundary (about half a mile away).

The only way to avoid the charge was to pay about US$20 to register as a resident within the zone, which the CCZ "service" company claim covers their costs in confirming my data. I wouldn't mind this if I had not already paid $210 for an annual residents parking permit, which required me to verify all the same data with the Westminster City Council, so I could park my vehicle on the street near our appartment.

So if you choose to pay (again) to register (again), a resident can purchase a pass that charges only 10% of the Congestion Zone Charge, but you can only purchase these by the week, not the day. Thus encouraging people who would otherwise drive out of the zone to use their vehicles to drive in the zone for a week.

Remove these sorts of weasley charges for no service or value to residents (who already pay a good chunk of their property taxes to the Greater London Authority that pays for London's public transport) and a New York Congestion Charge might not be a bad idea. But leave them in, and Mayor Bloomberg will be the least loved mayor of New York when history has it's say.

But why does New York need all the money from a Congestion Charge? Back to the advertising campaign. The claim is that the charge will pay for maintaining and upgrading the existing infrastructure.

'Back the charge or the transit system gets it!'

That seems a little unlikely. I think the true motive is to pay the multi-billion Dollar price tag for Mayor Bloomberg's pricey addition to the subway system: the 2nd Avenue line ($2bn in the making and that's just the first section!)

The ad campaign is supposed to persuade people in the already overcrowded (as bad as the London Tube in rush hour overcrowding) that the alternative to the charge is worse than the cost. Again, unlikely. It's a trifle to the super-rich on the Upper East Side, with whom Mayor Bloomberg mixes, and avoids the need to raise property taxes that would hit those same people a lot harder. It adds to the tax burden on people who already live in New York, and adds even more people to the over-loaded public transport system, without adding any real extra capacity to handle more people.

So if you live in New York city, outside or inside the zone, prepare to pay and pay and pay.