Thursday, April 1, 2010

Chasing the smart money up, down and sideways

If you watch the headlines and listen to the economic pundits two very different theme emerge: some people are worried about inflation (despite massive unemployment and a shortage of income), and urge cautious investments in solid items, like, say, gold. Others are laugh and point to the unemployment rate, the lack of consumer spending power and are still concerned with deflation.

This week there was news that should cause both camps to claim the moral high ground:

Virgin Blue (the 2nd largest Australian airline) is ordering 105 aircraft! Hurrah for Boeing - except that the price achieved was lower than 2001 levels. "Virgin Blue was fortunate to take advantage of the downturn in the market," chief executive, Brett Godfrey said. That's one way of putting it.....

In other news, prices are going up!

Good news for BHP and Rio Tinto, as iron ore miners have decided to scrap their annual pricing contracts and replace them with quarterly contracts from April 1st that more closely follow market spot-prices.

The net. effect of this scheme or scam, will mean a 30% rise in the price of steel, according to one interviewee on NPR. There is also the knock-on effect for metal bashers everywhere. Lest we forget, the last time someone tried imposing a 30% hike in the price of steel it was the Bush administration, who slapped a 30% import tariff on steel to prop up the US steel industry while it consolidated and restructured. That move prompted US metal bashers to go bust or move out of the US to Canada or Mexico where they could avoid the import tariff, use foreign steel and ship their products into the US tariff free via the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA).

As there are really only 3 iron ore miners left and two of them are forming a joint venture, so do we really have to wait until the damage is done before the Department of Justice's Anti-Trust unit starts looking into this? If the DoJ doesn't it looks like the Europeans will.

History is not encouraging and my bet is that speculative money drops gold and buys iron ore until the steel industry implodes.

Speaking of gold: gold is surely the most over-rated investment available today?

don't believe me, goldbugs? Well, if you bought Gold in 2002, you paid around $380 per Troy ounce and today it would be worth $1115 per Troy ounce. A 200% profit over ten years is roughly 20% per year and that's impressive. But if you bought Apple shares in 2002 they were $12 each, rose to $90 and split 2:1, and are currently trading at about $234 a share.

So $100,000 in 2002 invested in gold would now be worth $318,571. If you had invested that money in Apple you would now be worth $3,899,999. that's a 1,956% profit.

How did Apple do it? Simple: they innovated their way there with new products (the iPod) and invented new markets (iTunes store) rather than trying to game the market so brazenly.

If only miners were able to be as imaginative....