One of the big differences between the US and the UK is the provision of healthcare (or the lack of it). A lot of Americans believe their system provides them with the best healthcare money can buy. In most instances this is correct, but for a sizable number, the current system also leaves around 25-30 million people uninsured.
Outside the US it is widely assumed that 29 million Americans lacking health insurance just hope for the best when they get sick or curl up and die. The reality is somewhat more complex. Insured people fall into two catergories: those insured by their employers and those employed by their local state through the Medicare system. This also catches some people who are not insured by their employers (see, I told you this was complicated!) The uninsured usually end up using the Emergency Room (Accident & Emergency Dept., to the Brits), like a doctor's surgery and that costs 3-4 times what it would cost to provide primary healthcare for free.
Some authorities are recognising this and providing free basic medical services, like doctors clinics, to the uninsured, on the basis that this saves money. Of course, the whole aim of services in the US is to make money, so this is not terribly popular within the healthcare business.
The Good Lady Wife and I had a chance to sample the healthcare system recently, as she was feeling unwell. Arriving at the local ER, we were able to park in designated spaces directly opposite the entrance to the ER (compared to the average UK hospital, where with the struggle to find change to feed a meter and hobble across acres of parking space is designed to save them treating you). Next up was the front desk, where they asked what was wrong, our names, etc and then we were called around to a desk to go through the formalities of providing more details, insurance details, etc. We also had to pay a $50 'co-payment' (rather like the excess on a motor insurance policy, this is suppose to disward frivilous claims - as if anyone in their RIGHT MIND would go to hospital unless they needed to....). After a short wait to see a nurse, who was very good and thorough, took the usual reading, history, and so on a doctor was called over for a consult (I pick up all the lingo ;-D!), who came over in a matter of literally minutes (again, much better than the wait in the UK). After having taken a listen to Aim's chest for himself, pronounced his diagnosis ("You're not going to die and it's not your heart!") but just to be sure he ordered a chest x-ray and some blood work. The tests were done quickly, but we still ended up spending another 3 hours with the GLW hooked up to monitors and providing more blood samples (I started to wonder, 'should we have brought some garlic & holy water?!?')
Eventually, after a couple of hours, a doctor appeared (which was just as well, as the ESPN Classic documentary about the history of Soccer in the US was finished we were bored to the point of sleep!!) He pronounced that he was pretty sure the first doctor was right.... His perscription was basically 'go home, take some anti-inflamatories and get some rest, but if it flairs up again, come straight back.
The end result, much the same as the UK both in terms of time and result (you know you will never get back at least 3 hours of your life when you go to hospital and they will almost always say 'take two aspirin and lie down' unless you have broken something). The difference lay in the level of comfort in which we spent a lot of time waiting. So here's the thing: some people prefer the idea of the NHS in Britain as a model for America.
Having seen and heard about some of the rationing and target-fiddling done in the UK (hey, if there is a way to measure something, someone will find a way to cheat the measurements!), I think financial incentive measures for hospitals make them perform. If there is no money in NOT treating people then there is an incentive to treat them.
I think what the US could do with some form of universal insurance that provides access to doctors, but let people take out private or company insurance against major stuff like hospital operations, long term illness, etc. Perscriptions could be made cheaper if States and insurers ganged up on the pharma companies. The UK & Canada + most of Europe does it, so why not America?
Where you can find me
15 years ago