Wednesday, June 13, 2007

Multi-media-muddle

During the days of the Soviet Union there were two news sources in Russia: Izvestia (meaning news) and Pravda (meaning truth). The Russians had a say: There is no news in the Truth and no truth in the News!

It never cesses to amaze me how little information we really get, and how much is left out of the news. For all the talk about a free press and freedom of speech & information, there is very little useful out there, unless you dig for it.

But the worst thing about the impending end of oil is that may not be quite as soon as we think. There are several reasons for this, but the primary reason is that a lot of the information we read on a daily basis is filtered through the editorial processese of the media, which is to say, if an editor sees something one way, that is the news that's fit to print (as they used to say before radio, TV, and the web changed the media). If you only listen to the broadcast media you may be lucky to get about 10% of the available information and that 10% is the part that the TV producer thinks (a) you need to know (b) that you will understand and (c) he can fit in the two-minute window he has been given to cover a situation that fills days of conferences around the world every year.

But let's be honest: we would all fall asleep in information over-load if they tried to explain it properly. It is well known that Gordon Brown's reputation for being the best Chancellor since William Pitt the Younger is largely based on the same charade that Pitt's was: bamboozle the audience with economic mumbo-jumbo until they doze off.

To put it another way, imagine if God had tried to explain everything to Moses in detail:

"Yes, Moses, I made the world. ... Yes, it was a big job.... How long did it take? Well I wasn't really paying attention to the clock. As an eternal being who is omnipresent, it's a rather pointless excersie, isn't it?.... Om-ni-oh never mind......How did I make the world? We don't have time to go through galactic reciepes and cooking times or we'll never get done in your lifetime!..... Yes, I know people are going to ask about it, but they can figure it out for themselves later on - I did endow humanity with intelligence & reason after all! .... Look! If we stand around here while I bring you up to date since the beginning the Israelites will be wondering around the desert until the second coming ..... No don't ask about that or you'll have to explain the Trinity...... No, look, it's complicated! Just take this down: In the beginning......"

So, you can see why the media employs news editors to cut stuff down to manageable chunks and try to make it interesting by cutting a lot of the tricky stuff. But the problem is that sometimes you need more than the sound bite.

The problem with news editors is that if they don't know much about specific topics, and even their experts are usually forced to skip the difficult questions because they can't get an answer that will fit into a 20 second sound bite. So they tell you what they think you need to know, and you miss out on the things they cut out, even if not knowing might come back to bite you later on (like insurance companies' small print!). It gets worse, because if they don't want you to know at all, you probably never will. If you read a lot around a subject and do your own research you will quickly find how little news there is in the news. It's not that they lie (very often), just that they omit so much (like Whitehouse staffers claiming to Congress that they "don't remember" very much about the subject at hand).

So if you want to know what's really going on and how to navigate your way through the mess of media, do the same thing you would do to navitage. Pick multiple points of reference, sift through the data they provide and make up your own mind before someone makes it up for you.

But then again, as God might have said to Moses, "You just don't have a lifetime to get all that, just take this down....."